POEM: "God gives special children to special parents."
When I heard this, I wanted to punch the woman in the face.
Today I’d like to share with you some first thoughts when a woman from our former church stopped by during the first week after Sarah’s birth. She said, “God gives special children to special parents,” and this poem expresses my internal reaction, which I have never before given voice to.
“God gives special children to special parents”
she said, one week after Sarah’s birth—
One week after twenty-six hours of labor,
an unplanned c-section,
a hushed operating room.
One week since I’d heard the words
Apert syndrome
always in tandem with
twenty to sixty surgeries.
One week with
unanswerable questions that filled
the silence at night
and spaces between medical appointments.
I did not want a special child.
I was not a special parent.
I hated the treacly mention of God when in—
one week—
two of my friends birthed
healthy infants.
I did not.
Why was mine born with a rare diagnosis?
The woman smiled in my doorway,
offering the platitude, “God gives special children to special parents”
with a platter of food,
And I stared at her,
smiled
said thanks,
but all I could imagine
was slugging her in the face.
Here is a message from one of my paid subscribers. My hope is that each one of you feels seen, heard, valued, and appreciated in this digital space I have created here. In a world that contains so much division, one of my aspirations is to be a person who unites. Thank you for being here with me.
If you’ve ever heard a platitude while in a dark season of your life but needed a quiet, listening space instead, consider upgrading your subscription. I hold space for both the sacred and scared moments of your life.
Jeannie, I would have had a similar reaction. Thank you so much for courageously sharing this here, so that many more people can understand how platitudes such as this can be so damaging. Education around loss of all kinds is so badly needed in the UK and USA. Grrr!
I love your poem, Jeannie, but GAH I would also have wanted to slug that woman. And I know, I know people deserve some grace (I hope she at least brought good food) but I wish the people actually wading through grief didn't so often have to be the grace-givers.