Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Julie M Green's avatar

Oh Jeannie. I'm sorry- those criticisms weren't at all generous. I think there is always something positive to offer, and growth is possible even when a particular project doesn't have legs. So many writers (myself included!) have projects that have languished, while others eventually see the light of day. As you say, it's not in our power to know which is which. Our job is simply to show up and have faith that we have something worth saying.

Expand full comment
Doreen Frances's avatar

I'm so sorry that happened to you. I don't understand their need to be unkind in their feedback to you. How does that help? And even more so when you've put your whole life on the page for someone to criticize thoughtlessly. But your experience with the manuscript resonated with me. When I finished my third draft of my memoir manuscript, I thought it was "done" and I had some friends Beta Read it. One of them, whose opinion I very much respect, asked me "Why should we care about this story". Ugh. I thought I was ready to query agents! He was right and I thought that was helpful but I didn't touch it after that for five years. Those five years gave me an entire new perspective and I started at it again. When I did my fourth draft I decided to have a developmental editor look at it, I was given the name of someone highly recommended. When I spoke with them on the phone I knew that that person would NOT be right for me. I knew they thought more of their own self importance as a writer and "editor". My gut told me NO but I was swayed by the "recommendation". I went with my gut and I'm happy I did. I found a very kind but very helpful editor who gave me excellent feedback.

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts